How overvalued is the Stock Market?

Caveat: this analysis was conducted before the Russian invasion of Ukraine. 

You can find the complete analysis at the following two URLs:

Stock Overvaluation at Slideshare.net

Stock Overvaluation at SlidesFinder 

As a first cut, one looks at PE ratios and quickly infer that the Stock Market is much overvalued. 

Whether you look at a regular PE ratio or Shiller PE ratio (using 10 years of inflation adjusted earnings), PE ratios are pretty high right now.  But, on a stand alone basis a PE ratio does not tell you much if at all.  If the PE ratio of the S&P 500 is around 25, does it mean that stocks are expensive relative to bonds or other assets?  Does it mean that stocks are overvalued relative to the inflation rate or other economic indicators?  Frankly, you have no idea. 

To start our analysis, let's first look at whether stocks are overvalued or not relative to 10 Year Treasuries.  To render both investments comparable, we are going to flip the PE ratio upside down, and instead look at the EP ratio (Earnings/Price) that is commonly referred to as the Market Earnings Yield.  And, we are going to compare this Market EP with 10 Year Treasuries yield.  

As shown above, when we compare the S&P 500 earnings yield (EP) with 10 Year Treasuries yield (by dividing the former vs. the latter), we can observe that based on historical data the Stock Market appears relatively cheap or undervalued relative to 10 Year Treasuries yield. 

We can extend this analysis to all different types of bonds, and the result is the same.  Currently, stock are actually a lot cheaper than bonds. 

The table above shows on the first row that the EP multiple of 10 Year Treasury is currently 2.2.  It is much higher than the long term average of 1.3.  Also, the EP - 10 Year Treasury yield spread is 1.73%, which is 1.47% higher than the long term average of 0.27%.  Given that, stocks are currently a lot cheaper than 10 Year Treasuries.  And, the story is the same for 30 Year Treasuries, Moody's Baa corporate bonds, and S&P BB and B rated bonds.  Thus, despite the S&P 500 having a pretty high PE, stocks are actually really cheap relative to bonds.  But, does that mean that stocks are truly cheap or undervalued?  Or, that bonds are even more overvalued than stocks.  

The table below discloses that stocks and bonds are actually all rather extraordinarily expensive relative to the current inflation rate. 

Looking at the first column from the left, the S&P 500 Earnings Yield (EP) is - 3.65 percentage points lower than the inflation rate over the past 12 months.  And, that is - 3.64 standard deviation below the long term average for this spread that stands at + 2.17%.  Thus, from this standpoint the stock market is greatly overvalued.  Notice, that it is the same story for all the bonds.

One can reasonably argue that the stocks and bonds overvaluation is very much due to a one-off abrupt spike in inflation that should abate somewhat over the next year or so.    

In January 2022, inflation, measured as the 12 month change in CPI, jumped to 7.5%.  This was the highest inflation rate since the early 1980s.  

Next, let's look at a more stable measure of inflation.  It is also forward looking which makes it very relevant for the stock market.  That measure is the 10 Year Inflation Expectation derived by measuring the spread between regular 10 Year Treasuries and Inflation Indexed 10 Year Treasuries.  The current spread between the two is 2.45%, in line with long term average.  Now, let's look at the valuation of stocks and bonds relative to this inflation expectation measure. 

As shown, even using this more stable measure of inflation, stocks and bonds are still very much overvalued relative to inflation expectations. 

We can look at two linear regression models to explore in more detail how overvalued are stocks relative to inflation and inflation expectations. 

The linear regression on the left shows that given a current inflation rate of 7.5%, the estimated stock market EP is 9.0% vs. an actual figure of 3.83%.  For the mentioned reasons, we won't focus much on this model and this inflation measure.  Instead, we will focus more on the less volatile and more forward looking inflation expectation measure and the related model within the scatter plot on the right.  

The linear regression on the right shows that given a current 10 year inflation expectation of 2.45%, the estimated stock market EP is 5.33% vs. an actual figure of 3.83%.  Focusing on the 10 year inflation expectation measure, it would entail a potential market correction of: 3.83%/5.33% - 1 = - 28%.  Notice that this regression model is not that explanatory (R Square 0.27).  So, there is much uncertainty around this potential market correction estimate.  Nevertheless, the current EP of 3.83% is 1.4 standard error below the estimate of 5.33%, indicating that 92% of this regression model residuals are higher than for this current observation.  That is pretty far out on the left-tail.